Every year, there are people claiming it's the worst FM ever, as well as many say it's the best. And every year, there are weird things, injuries, impossible goals and stuff. I haven't encountered any such monstrosity in FM15 yet, but I believe some players do, as well as some are just complaining because they don't agree with something that's not really wrong or bugged (injuries, shots off target, losing streaks...). If you like FM, it's worth it. It's completely playable, so even if you're disappointed by anything, it's not a complete waste of money. Also, the price is well below 50 euros, even below 25 euros at some retailers.
1