2020-06-24 15:06#274767 lfcfan1892ph : Thanks Mercia for responding
I'll definitely give dropping the mentality back a notch or two a go. My tactic that I typically used was on attacking but moving it down to positive could be quite helpful since I typically found that my team would get smashed on counter attacks so it might help. What team and type of players are you using in your save where you've had consistent success, just so I know what level your team is on compared to the one I am using. Do you mind letting me know what tactic you are using, just so I have a bit of an idea how to fix mine maybe to be more functional?
Again thanks for responding, hope you are well
I use this tactic and have only made slight changes over the years

York are about to compete in the Championship playoffs after going from NAtional North all the way up, with 4 promotions in 4 years with 3 league titles along the way, worth noting I do not buy many players, the players in the screen have mostly come with me from at least League 2, we were predicted to be relegated, as usual, yet have comfortably finished in Playoff places.
Playing a few PL sides over the years, including beating Liverpool in the League Cup

1