
I chose this formation because it gives me all what Carlo want, defensive midfielder like Alonso, two wingers that cuts inside (but can use them as he used them in defense, where they returned back). In addition, I can easily incorporate two central midfielders, in this case Modric and Di Maria / Isco.

I'll start with the mentality that in most games is Control in the beginning, I change during the game depending on the results. I was hesitant about Standard and Control, but I still think that in this case the second choice is better; dose of caution, but also plenty of attacking football.
And when selecting the fluidity I was in doubt, put the Balanced or Fluid, but also here the choice fell to number two. I expected that the players participate in the game in all aspects, so will the offensive-oriented players contribute defensively.
Player instructions
When we set special instructions for each player, then we will start from the goalkeeper. In this case most similar option is Sweeper keeper to Defend like Diego Lopez was last season; without unnecessary outbreak and stand at about 10-11 meters from the goal. Ancelotti preferred that because of high defense line, and because Ramos and Pepe often played too high and, in this case, the goalkeeper was the last player.

Goalkeeper
Ancelotti perfected roles for fullbacks only in second half of season, putting Marcelo to go more forward while Carvajal remained a little behind, or if it is left Coentrao, Carvajal to gain more freedom. So I decided to put Complete wing back on left side, while the right was full back - Support, precisely for this reason - balance.

Marcelo

Carvajal
In heart of defence are two different types of defenders. In this case, Ramos was the one who was most moved forward with the ball (Ball Playing Defender - Defend) and Pepe or Varane were slightly withdrawn behind (Central Defender - Cover) high defense line.

Ramos

Ball Playing Defender - Defend
Defensive midfielder, Xabi Alonso had a special role. He was playmaker and anchor man, played defensively a lot, but it's also been one of those who start attacks - conductor. In the world of FM that role wasn't available until FM14 - Half back. When Ramos came highly with the ball (thus the whole line of defense), he withdrew and was the fifth defender and even a little behind and to allow extra option, and if the team without the ball, plays standard defensive mid who got only one job - to stop opponent.

Xabi Alonso
Duo in midfield are Luka Modric and Angel di Maria. A slightly different role was that of Argentinian in midfield. Although he is a winger by itself, he has shown how useful can be in the central mid role. His role in FM we can describe as a Central Midfielder - Attack with that is often passed through on the left (when Ronaldo cuts inside and leave space on the left side), so we could see that against Barca (two assists from the left flank). Modric is a classic playmaker (Advanced Playmaker - Support), and against stronger teams Ancelotti may assign him a more defensive role alongside Alonso (Deep-lying playmaker - Support).

Luka Modric

Angel di Maria
There is no need to describe role for Ronaldo and Bale. Simply, they are Inside forwards - attack and there's nothing to say except that they will be the ones who will break the defense line with dribbling, shots... Actually, they are in FM exactly what are they in real-life.

Ronaldo

Bale
Benzema's role this season has brought many good things in the game of Real Madrid. The whole season he played "false nine" (F9) which allowed Ronaldo and Bale to cut inside. There's nothing more to say except that he will come for the ball deep, and of course he will assist and score.
Opposition instructions
In order to better close the center and ball flow through that part, I tried to close all offensive players. I often closed wingers tightly, but should pay attention to the opponent's fullbacks that can cause problems if they play offensively, but can also help if you use your counter-attacks. I recommend you to read some tutorial about OI so you can be prepared for this.
Other notes and tips
- During the pre-season, I used 'Fitness' in General training with Very high intesity and 'Tactics' in Match preparation. Through the season, I changed it, so in General training it was 'Team Cohesion' and in Match preparation it was 'Att. movemant'
- If you have a lead of two or more goals, about 60th minute, gently try to close the match with these instructions.
- If you lead with one goal, and you think that opponent can score the equalizing goal (about 15 minutes left) also try to close the game with the instructions below and with Counter mentality.
- If you are losing in 60th minute try to speed up the pace (Higher tempo), and if you are losing in 75th minute put all cards in attack with the instructions below.
- If the opponent plays with two strikers, it wouldn't be good to set Tight marking on 'Always' to both strikers (Opposition ins). You must recognize which one is poacher and then put Tight marking-Always on him (his teammate in attack don't need to be closed to much).
- This tactic has been tested in patch 14.3.1 and I can’t guarantee it is working in later patches.
Tactic in action
In attack
I used a situation from the start of the match. Our wingers aren't required to do much in defence, so our two central midfielders try to close down opponents fullbacks as best as they can (in this case Modric), and then winger come little deeper to hold mid's back. You can also see that we are very thick in the middle so the opponent don't have to much space in that coridor (opponent's attacker is alone between our two central defenders.)

On picture above you can see real role of Gil Romero (otherwise there is Alonso). He is in half-back role here. We are trying to get rid from the pressing and now Denswil gets free space, he of course takes it and pass ball to Modric who plays one-two with Isco and counter-attack is ready. In this situation half-back is our other option to play simple without giving ball to the opponents.

In attack biggest role plays Benzema (F9). In many cases he is key player which can be seen here. He comes deep to get ball, then Ronaldo becomes an attacker while Isco try to distract opponents to another side, and free space is now open to Marcelo (who is Complete wing back). Then full back is moving forward and passing the ball to Ronaldo who is in mat position.

Again we see Benzema in action. Although in this attack he is passive (didn't touch the ball), he dragged two defenders high, while Ronaldo and Bale ran into space. Isco has decided to pass to Ronaldo, but the opposition full back was faster and intercept the ball. In addition, we can see Marcelo run and he could be assisted by Isco and would, most likely, Ronaldo and Bale had a goal opportunity.

Benzema, Benzema, Benzema. I know, always Benzema, but he is key in this kind of tactic (to be precise, one of key players). We are out from opposition pressing, Modric plays ball to Benzema who pass ball from first touch to Ronaldo and he assist to Bale who scores.
Changes in version 2
- Added in Team ins: Drill crosses, Exploit the flanks and Allow wide players to swap
- Removed from Team ins: Push higher up
- Changes in Player ins: DCR and DCL now have Close down more option and ST have Roam from position
Try older versions:
Version 1
Discussion: Ancelotti's Real Madrid 2013-14 for FM14 (version 2)
24 comments have been posted so far.
1) This captures the basic, and fundamental game plan of Real Madrid. Solid midfield dominance using versatile central midfielders, using Benzema to create space, which lets them take full advantage of Bale and Ronaldo's athleticism and technical prowess. The defense line shifts accordingly to continue the ball from flowing among themselves, and naturally maintaining possession.
2) At the same time, by not choosing a drastic fludity/mentality and a specific def. line and tempo, this tactic captures the cornerstone of every great manager: Flexibility. So many FM tactics that users post are unable to capture this. They cannot escape their myopic and lazy definition of how managers choose to play the game. (i.e. Ancelotti likes the 4-4-2Diamond. Villas-Boas plays with defenders high up the pitch). This makes the said tactic way too rigid, and I am unable to respond to changing circumstances throughout the season and in matches. So far, I feel that yours and the "Brendan Rogers System" are the among the very few tactics that make a true attempt at capturing the essence of the tactical philosophy of their selected models. By studying this tactic among others I learned a lot about FM2014 and of course, football.
For a long time I felt a certain disdain towards people coming up with short, rigid definitions of a manager's tactics. At the top level, no manager is a one trick pony, and they are all flexible to adjust to different squads and changing circumstances. They may have a certain philosophy, but the way they employ them largely depends on the team they have at their disposal and their opponents. For example the football Jose Mourinho played at Chelsea, Real Madrid, and Inter are quite different. This flexibility is absolutely necessary for a manager to be great, and Ancelotti is no different.
For a FM player to really capture that very essence of a tactic he needs to first understand the model they are trying to replicate, and this is a hard ask. It takes the most dedicated fan to recognize the elements that really make the tactic what it is. Granted, since I am a Manchester United fan, I do not get to watch that many Real Madrid games, but I really feel that this tactic is as close to the kind of football I see in Ancelotti's Madrid. This depth of understanding can only come from true devotion to this beautiful game and the team that we love. Thank you for your hard work. Playing with your tactics and studying it really made my football viewing, both through FM and in real life, more entertaining.
I wouldn't sell them either, if I had to sell one it would be Isco because his physicals are bad, but he is one of the most technically gifted players at Real Madrid (or even in the game, reminds me of Ronaldinho).
1-marcelo does not stay wider, he cuts inside. also, both WB look to track back instead of closing down more, as both cristiano and bale do not defend at all. tight marking and close down less should be their instructions.
2-the stopper style CB are pepe and varane (defend in your tactic), they're not cover type. the cover role is reserved to sergio ramos, as he is the fastest among the 3 of them. i agree though ramos is the BPD and has attacking personal instructons (go forward).
3-xabi alonso does not play as a HB at all! he plays as a DLP defend, a DM defend at most! Half Back moves through the pitch way more than alonso does, who sticks to his area without moving from there. i wouldn't give him an anchor man role though, as he has huge playmaking responsibilities. he also does not play only short passes, and looks constantly for through balls, either flat passes or long balls to the wings. the way you set his instructions, he plays more as busquets does in barça than as he actually does in madrid.
4-luka modric does not close down more. he indeed is the first stopper in the MC line, while di maria does close down more and presses in the AMC line. but modric sits deep, almost in line with alonso when defending, though a little bit higher (achieved by his position basically, not mentallity nor instructions)
benzema role you're right it's been kind of a false nine, although i would set him as DLF support, as he is not as roaming as the F9 role, he moves into channels more than fall to wings.
on general instructions i agree with almost everything, except maybe for the overlap one. as i said, marcelo does cut inside and plays as a playmaker from there, so a CWB role with those instructions is the optimal. carvajal instead acts as a natural WB, attacking when able and supportive or even defensive depending on the opponent. he does overlap, so a personal instruction of get further forward is needed. also i have my doubts that real madrid presses high as you set them, i would leave all pressing instrunctions blank except maybe for the "get stuck in" one. also, i miss there the "run against defence" one.
as i said, this may be a wonderful tactic as everything is logical and well thought, although it is not realistic in replicating ancelotti's tactics with RM.
So, Real' defense are at most time of the match at 22-25 meters from goal, and sometimes little higher. When Bilbao was at their half, Real Madrid was at 22 meters (approximately) and when Bilbao tried to dribble at defence, they were retrieving for about two meters.
Now is question; if I am using 'drop deeper', how much will defense drop back? Right now, when I didn't selected either 'drop deeper' or 'push higher up', my defence were at 22-25 meters what is for me quite good?
Opposition on the other half: https://fmshots.com/bk/nufifKJ.png and https://fmshots.com/bk/kyEZeHj.png
Opposition at their half: https://fmshots.com/bk/M6u9I05.png and https://fmshots.com/bk/sJOsNJh.png
Opposition are trying to dribble through: https://fmshots.com/bk/YiDPxUt.png
@CroMadridista: I appreciate your calm reactions to the criticism you received.
Good luck and I wish you all the best! Kind regards, Jat
In this video (consider that this is just one game) you can see that Ramos and Pepe are very often at the middle of the pitch. You are totally wrong when you say that Ancelotti ALWAYS plays deep. They played deep in some matches like that vs Bayern, and Barcelona for example.
Sorry you expert, I didn't noticed you
btw. I am here for presenting tactic of Ancelotti and I will always stand by choice of mine, but of course I will also accept critics from other including from you ("football expert")...
@guilhermebastos Here are some result from first season with Real Madrid while I was testing tactic...
LL: https://fmshots.com/bk/QhvBiWf.jpg
CL: https://fmshots.com/bk/vc5bg0R.jpg
CdR: https://fmshots.com/bk/hgmTpaq.jpg
I will try and say my impressions!
Do you had good results?
Thanks, and sorry for my bad english
In 4-3-3 (4-5-1 in my way) he often used something between 'push higher up' and 'drop deeper' (teaser: I am now testing tactic in second season and there are some changes including that. So in new version I won't use either push higher up or drop deeper).
I am using control before balanced so my team is cautious about opponents counter-attacks but also is very productive in attack (just like Real Madrid do).
Drill crosses are added in new version but thanks anyway for that tip, I missed it. Now about tempo: Real Madrid last season was too slow in beginning (with Khedira in mid and with pure 4-3-3 tactic) and in second half of season he moved Di Maria to midfield and that was key. Every match Real started pretty slow and then they became faster and faster (if they need speed; depends on the result). So, I didn't select higher or slower tempo on the beginning of the match and I am changing it depending on the result.
I watched every Real Madrid's match for last three years (of course including last one) and I am pretty sure about my view of this tactic, but of course I am open for sugestions like yours and they are welcome
btw. if I made some mistakes in writing, don't blame on me, I am Croat and don't speek English perfectly.