Search
On FM Scout you can chat about Football Manager in real time since 2011. Here are 10 reasons to join!

Christiano Ronaldo, Ronaldinho, Lionel Messi Or Kaka ?

Started on 29 February 2008 by torres
Latest Reply on 7 June 2011 by l3nnart
  • POSTS55
  • VIEWS80325
Pages  
First of all, people you seem retarded to me to compare players who don't seem to play in the same position and roles in the pitch!
First Cristiano could have been the best in real life but seems that he fully lacks of team work and work rate and to me he is more than a complete forward than a winger he can score with all the ways possible or not and he got all the stats to support the ultimate forward such as Van Basten!
Messi is the best player in the world cause he tries hard in the pitch and he is not playing alone since he is not only a top goalscorer for Barca but a top assist man too! Messi is not a complete forward cause he lacks heading and jumping and height he is more than a winger too I could position him in a fast striker or peripherical striker just like rooney with a lot of free role!
Ronaldinho was one of the best since he started to celebrate his golden boot with whores booze and drugs he lost all mentality!
Kaka was a footballer with great pontential in Milan but since his last grave injuries in Madrid he lost the flair and the mood i guess to stretch his abilities further he is done to me just like Ronaldinho!
P.S Kaka is a classic AMC while Ronaldinho was a left winger who needed a lot of space so as to dribble and cut inside just like Henry! Messi is not a winger and based in body stats and mentality CR7 is not a winger in Madrid too ( he is a scorer)!
Messi gets most goals an assist because every Barca attack HAS to go though him, it almost seems like the rest of the team got OCD or someting like that... you can't say ronaldo lacks workethic, when have you ever seen prof of him not working his ass of ?
Ronaldo may work his ass on trainig, but in the pitch he just gives up when he loses the ball, that's what I call lack of workethic!

I think we can compare them since they are all great players and every one of them is able to play an attacking position, only Kaka is out of reach in this matter because he's an AMC! But as for CR9, Messi or Ronaldinho, they can all play every attacking position like AMC, winger or striker!

@ |3ennart:

All barça attacks pass thru messi because he his the most creative player there, I'm not referring to his passing abilities or to his killer passes, but the way he can surpass defenders, there's no one like him! It looks like he's got a magnet inside the ball and his shoes are made of metal!!
yeha, but I bet you he's never recived instruktions to work in the defence to regain possesion either, that's not his job, but he does apply pressure to the defence as he's supposed to... and honestly, have you ever seen messi working his ass of in the defensive work?...

well yes, he's the best players in barca by far, and his technique (not meaning tricks but just plain and simple touch and control) is from another world. But I stand by what I've said earlier, Ronaldo is more complete
Even if he is more complete, he doesn't use all his skills then! some become hindered by his lack of intelligence! :P

But I think we are getting to the point where the question is just a matter of personal taste :D

I can only wish that Ronaldo plays like he did back in Man Utd, for Portugal in EURO cup 2012! We have the quality and the players to go all the way, let's see how it goes!!
well he did out-score messi this year and he was definetly one of the main reasons that real won atleast one game this year against barcelona, so I'd say it's more an issue of real being unlucky to have played all their key matches this year against barcelona... not to say I think barcelona are as superior as people claim, but the fact is that the only approach possible against them doesn't allow the oppositions strikers to shine much... just look att roney and hernandez...
# l3nnart : Messi gets most goals an assist because every Barca attack HAS to go though him, it almost seems like the rest of the team got OCD or someting like that... you can't say ronaldo lacks workethic, when have you ever seen prof of him not working his ass of ?
whats OCD?
I'm not sure exactly what the "O" stands for, but the "CD" is "compulsuary disorder", meaning that they feel the need to do it...
My guess is that the "O" stands for obsessive! :)
well guess that makes sense

You are reading "Christiano Ronaldo, Ronaldinho, Lionel Messi Or Kaka ?".

FMS Chat

Stam
hey, just wanted to let you know that we have a fb style chat for our members. login or sign up to start chatting.