Search
On FM Scout you can chat about Football Manager in real time since 2011. Here are 10 reasons to join!

Ter Stegen or Ron-Robert Zieler

Who do you believe is a better buy
Started on 31 March 2014 by stemac92
Latest Reply on 1 April 2014 by stemac92
  • POSTS4
  • VIEWS8950
 
Im currently Liverpool, just finished my first season. Looking to sign a first team/backup keeper to compete with mignolet.

  • Ter Stegen - 22 - £8.5 mil / 43k
  • Zieler - 25 - £5.5 mil / 41k
ter Stegen wouldn't really be backup, perhaps Zieler would but if he won't play often you'll want an older keeper so he won't be lOsing development.
I had both at Man City.

ter Stegen should be 1st choice. Absolutely quality, but from my experience, very expensive.

Zieler hates being a back-up, and that's what I used him as. My opinion is he is not good enough to be first team.

My advice would be to keep Mignolet and not buy a new goalie. FM isn't like real life in players needing competition, and my goalkeepers have rarely become injured and never become complacent.

If my keeper is 3* + then I simply buy/loan or extend the contract of a 2-2.5* goalkeeper. Alternatively, bring one of your academy's goalkeepers through the system.

I've had Fabianski as a back-up and bought a guy called Michael Agazzi as a back-up for £2 Million. I rarely had to use either of them, but they are sufficient players and never complain about the lack of first team football. I also have Martinez as a third, just in case.
Thanks guys, went for Ter Stegen as it was a bargain. Play him in the Prem and CL games and Mignolet in FA and League Cups. Both happy so far so fingers crossed.

You are reading "Ter Stegen or Ron-Robert Zieler".

FMS Chat

Stam
hey, just wanted to let you know that we have a fb style chat for our members. login or sign up to start chatting.