On FM Scout you can chat about Football Manager in real time since 2011. Here are 10 reasons to join!

Newcastle - The Toon Rising

Started on 29 December 2017 by Musonda
Latest Reply on 2 January 2018 by Justice
  • POSTS5
  • VIEWS8496
The Toon Rising


So firstly an introduction to myself, I thought I'd make my first post on this forum worthwhile! I've been an avid FM player since 2005 and prior to that Champ Manager for several years too. I do a lot of writing in my spare time, and as well as playing FM I thought I'd try to combine the two for the purpose of this post, and others beyond it!

That brings me on nicely to where I am with this save. Since picking up this years' FM a couple of months ago, I have struggled to get into it mainly with time constraints but also after loading 4/5 saves I've really struggled with the game, and found it pretty difficult. I class myself as a reasonably good player, so my struggles this year did surprise me. I don't like using other people's tactics for serious saves, each to their own but I like to make my own and I think I was guilty of being too complex with the ones I made and quite frankly it was getting me nowhere, other than being sacked! So I decided to load up lots of leagues across a number of different countries and sit back and take a look at who I should manage. After much deliberation, I decided Newcastle...

The Aim

'Huge potential', 'Too big a club to go down', two quotes that always seem to be associated with Newcastle. However it's time to be realistic, the club have been relegated twice in the past 10 years, and with unstable ownership to put it lightly, as well as no sign of being close to European football or any trophies something definitely had to change. That's why I decided this would be the perfect challenge to take up. I will go on to what the club wanted me to achieve in the next mini-segment, however these were my personal (lofty) aims for this season:

- Successfully overview the sale of the club to new owners
- Finish within touching distance/scrape a Europa League spot
- Sign young players who will become first team stars in later years
- Have a strong cup run

I thought these were 4 reasonable and ambitious aims for the season. Obviously the ownership matter is out of my control, however I was hoping this could be sorted over a season as it's heading that way in real life. The Europa League spot did seem slightly lofty based on where Newcastle are at the moment, but I felt with the right additions this would be possible. I always look to build young squads, and unlike previous FM saves I've had I really want to build a 'dynasty' of sorts here so I needed to look forward and sign players I felt could help achieve this. Finally Newcastle fans have been dreaming of silverware for many years, I vowed to take the cups seriously and see if I could help achieve an elusive trophy this season.


Mike Ashley, who many perceive as the 'outgoing' Chairman due to his vested interest in selling the club (as you will find out later) tasked me with a mid-table finish, as well as a transfer budget of around £13m plus free wages remaining of about £100k. I saw this as reasonable, and after looking at the squad there is certainly enough talent there to do what I needed to do this season. See below my in/out activity.


Quick spoiler, as you can see this image does contain the two January signings I made in Fiete Arp (Loan) and Malang Sarr, however I'm displaying this update as a full season review so it made sense to include them.

So the signings then. I quickly identified Central Midfield and in particular the 'Ball Winning' midfielder area in my 4-2-2-2/4-2-3-1 formations (which I will show you later) as areas we were lacking. Sturaro is a player I've had on previous editions, and was available at a snippet of his true value of £6.5m from Juve. We fought off big European completion for him so I was pleased to get that one over the line. As I mentioned previously, I was fairly happy with my squad and so I focussed the rest of my window(s) on young talent. Joe Rankin-Costello a highly rated midfielder was signed from Blackburn, at 16 he has a huge future ahead and I know he's being touted in real life with moves to the likes of Man City & Arsenal so I was excited about his prospect. Ezri Konsa, another young British CB was signed from Charlton with bags of potential. Incidentally as you'll see in the outgoings both were loaned back to their former clubs for the season. Strikers Chuma and Joel Piroe were brought in. Chuma a low-risk free transfer who will spend the season with our U23s, and Piroe an 18 year old Dutchman from PSV's youth side. We secured the loans of Dominic Calvert-Lewin, and James Wilson. Both young Englishman who will bolster our squad and make sure we can compete across all fronts, also nice to have some more homegrown players on our books. Finally Lautaro Martinez joined, this was the transfer I was most excited about. One of Europe's most coveted young strikers' who has the world at his feet. What impressed me the most was both PSG and Man City were interested, but we fought them off with the lure of first team football. However the downfall & huge risk was that he failed his work permit application, I was in two minds as to cancel the transfer altogether but I decided to take the plunge as I couldn't let that potential slip, and worst case scenario we would make a tidy profit.


As you can see, numerous outgoings. I won't go through them individually but I will summarise. Jack Colback was moved on, who was replaced by Sturaro. I didn't feel he had the quality to start and his big wages were offputting so I decided to cash in. Massimo Haidara was moved on, with the arrival of Brad Smith as cover for LB preceding him and he was making noises about wanting to go. Across the pitch at Right-Back, Jesus Gamez was sat in my reserves on big wages so I decided to loan him out and wind down his contract. Henri Saivet was a weird one. I immediately loaned him out to Southampton, recalled after realising I probably should have kept him as backup and then was set to keep him for the season, but Swansea came in with a 100% wage paid loan offer plus monthly fee and after not making my first few matchday squads I decided to let him go, as I was most likely going to sell him in the Summer anyway. The rest of the activity was youth being loaned. Most notably Martinez who was loaned to Besiktas to help obtain his work permit and get first team football, thankfully this didn't take long at all and he was recalled in January after receiving his permit surprisingly in December and proving to be pivotal for us in the second half of the season. A quick one on January too, both Ciaran Clark and Mo Diame were surplus to requirements so they were shipped off for reasonable transfer fees.

Season Review

Premier League

What an unbelievable campaign for Newcastle Football Club! I will explain just how we did it, but firstly just to say this vastly exceeded my ambitions. As I posted above, the club wanted a top half finish, and I targeted a Europa League (7th) placed finish really at best. In addition based on my recent FM18 experiences I was half expecting to be sacked and to end up with egg on my face, but how these boys proved me wrong! Here is the breakdown.

The first half of the season saw a mixed bag really. Whilst I was chopping and changing with tactics we did hit peaks and troughs in form. I felt after the first 19 we were pretty much on 'Europa League' or Top-Half form. We struggled against the bigger sides as expected, losing to Spurs, Manchester United, Liverpool and Chelsea however picked up credible points at home to Arsenal and away to Man City. During the other games, bar the disaster of newly promoted Huddersfield at home, we pretty much did as we needed to do. Strong home victories against Southampton and Everton as well as coming from 2 goals down to beat Burnley 3-2 away at Turf Moor impressed me. After 19 games we totalled 34 points, which on projection should get us 68 which I felt was 5th/6th place form, I was more than happy!

The second half of the season is really where our campaign dramatically changed. Only 2 losses from 19, the latter against West Ham I will be going on to (ffs). However we really did hit form. Actually we were unbeaten in the league from our 2nd of December defeat against Chelsea, all the way through to a 3-1 loss at Swansea on April 16th. An incredible run and I couldn't have been happier with my team throughout. The wins that most stood out for me were the 2-0 and 1-0 reversals of Liverpool and Manchester United respectively who both beat us away from home. This took a lot of guile especially playing them back to back but we did extremely well, and at that point I thought our top 4 push was credible.

After escaping Chelsea at home with 3 points, and grabbing a last gasp equaliser away at the Emirates, amazingly we were in with a shout of lifting the title. We hadn't lead the league at any point yet we had as good a shout as ever to lift the title in my first season in charge! An awful performance at Swansea saw us lose pace, but after beating Burnley and Man City we went into the last game on 77 points, with both Arsenal (75) and Chelsea (76) behind us! All we had to do was get a result away at West Ham, and I held a positive team meeting pre-match, I thought this was the moment. We even went 1-0 up and I began to pop the champagne. However, too our horror we absolutely crumbled, we decided to put in our worst performance of the season when it mattered most. We were absolutely played off the park and I can have zero complaints on the day, Chelsea won their game and it just wasn't to be, the dream was over.

As strange as it sounds, I never really thought we would win it. We came from absolutely nowhere and I actually felt it was going to be 'too soon' to win the league if there is such a thing. Winning the title was part of my 3-5 year plan, and to achieve it at the first time of asking would have really lost my interest in the save, and expectations would be so high going forward. Despite losing it the way we did, a remarkable season from the boys, and Champions League football would be back at St James's Park for the first time in over 15 years since a certain Alan Shearer was banging them in. What a campaign!

Cup Competitions

Carabao Cup

Not much to report here. We struggled hugely. After scraping through ties against Fleetwood on penalties, and a late winner at home to Preston we set up a tie against our bitter, recently relegated rivals Sunderland. Having played fringe players in the first two ties, I actually opted for a near enough full strength side against the Black Cats. I knew how much this game meant to the fans, and due to Sunderland's relegation they were starved of some Tyne-Wear action. Unfortunately we really weren't at our best, and were outplayed by our rivals for 90 minutes. That sent us out of the cup and I had a lot of making up to do with our fans, hopefully our league campaign went some away to wipe away this disaster!

FA Cup

Not the easiest of draws, but we did make a credible effort to the Quarter Finals before losing to Arsenal. Despite my earlier promise of an aim of challenging for silverware, our league campaign in the second half of the season was in full swing and as it was going much better than expected, the cup did take a back seat. We scraped past Villa despite going 4-0 up courtesy of a brace for debutant Lautaro Martinez then let 3 second half goals in to make it a nailbiter. We then scraped another win against Everton at home, goals from the underused Joselu and Isaac Hayden safely saw us through. A last gasp equaliser from Martinez earned us a replay at St James's with Burnley, which we duly dispatched 2-0 with goals from Mitrovic and again Martinez who was proving a star since his return from loan in January. Arsenal was always going to be a stretch, a largely 2nd string side put in a good effort but Arsenal were too strong and the Cup run ended at the 6th round. Not a bad run, and we go again next season!

Player Stats - My Feedback

Player Of The Season - Christian Atsu

A phenomenal season from our Ghanaian winger. He excelled in the left wing position of our 4-2-2-2 chipping in with a mammoth 16 goals and 15 assists in the league, therefore involving himself in 31 goals in 38 league games. Pre-season I thought we might struggle for goals with Dwight Gayle, Mitrovic and Joselu not really being 20+ goal men so it needed someone like Atsu from the midfield/wing to step up and he did. Some extremely important goals and assists lead him to becoming our club player of the season, and finished 3rd overall in the PFA player of the year, a fantastic achievement and a bumper new contract was earned.

Honourable mention to a few other players. Matt Ritchie who was Atsu's counterpart had a stunning season. 7 goals and 7 assists don't seem like excellent numbers, but they all came in big games and he was very important to the side. Aside from Ritchie, the striker pairing of Dwight Gayle and Aleksandar Mitrovic chipped in with 13 and 14 goals respectively. A strong effort from two players who I didn't feel would set the world alight but did what they needed to do for us up front and touching 30 goals between them is a very reliable effort. Lautaro Martinez was a phenomenon when returning from loan. 8 goals in 18 appearances for the 19 year old who scored 5 of those 18 in his first 4 games before going on a drought. He picked himself up and he will certainly be the one to watch next season, I was absolutely delighted to get that over the line ahead of some big club competition and to sort out his work permit earlier than expected. However I doubt we will be hearing the last of possible suitors and it will take continued success to keep this man in Tyneside for the foreseeable!

In the midfield Stefano Sturaro won a lot of plaudits for his gritty performances in the BWM role. He picked up his fair share of bookings, and 2 sendings off but he complimented Jonjo Shelvey very well, and allowed the playmaker to focus on goal scoring and assisting exploits.

Finally at the back, a special mention to all 4 of the starting defenders who were pivotal to our 2nd place finish this season. The youthful pairing of Jamal Lascelles and Chancel Mbemba proved mature beyond their years in an astounding campaign. I was worried going into the season if they would be strong enough but both avoided injury and were vital to our successes. Likewise with our fullbacks De-Andre Yedlin on the right and Welsh international Paul Dummett were pointed out by many managers as our suspected weak link and I have to say initially I thought this too. However both averaged over a 7 for the season, and with a lack of cover on both sides did well to keep fit and sustain continuity at the back alongside the two centre halves.

Other Information

I'll keep this brief, but some other information to shape next season's campaign:

- Premier League Manager of the Year went to myself. Of course I'd have preferred the title, but the award did well for my Manager points and was well received!
- Mike Ashley sold the club! A Tycoon who is a 'local businessman' Peter Bishop tied up a deal in February, and as you'll see next season awarded me a bumper budget and hopefully will secure the future of this club
- There will be at least one derby next year, not the Tyne-Wear but the Tyne-Tees derby will be back as Boro' won the Championship. Aston Villa return after finishing 2nd, as do Hull who came up via the play-offs
- Belgium lifted their first World Cup in 2018 beating Germany 4-0 in the final


Well I hope you enjoyed reading my exploits this season. Please let me know any feedback on the writing style, any constructive criticism is welcome! I'd like to continue doing the 'season review' formats as opposed to monthly updates as I prefer to play it then review rather than a stop/start setup.

Next season we will aim to go one better and try to lift the Premier League against all odds, and we welcome Champions League football back at the iconic St James's Park, I can't wait!

Many Thanks For Reading
Please can you post your NUFC tactics as I am really struggling to get a performance out of them
Season Two - Second Season Syndrome?


*Quick side note before I get into it. I wrote out this piece in pretty much it's entirety last night but as I was just about to write the conclusion my laptop crashed and I lost the whole piece! Seeing as it took about an hour of my time I was pretty annoyed, therefore this is likely to be a scaled down version but I'll still cover all the key points.

So last season was an extremely successful one for us. After being set with expectations of a top half finish by (former) Chairman Mike Ashley, and with myself looking to secure a Europa League spot we did far better and came within one game of lifting the Premier League title, ultimately finishing 2nd just behind Chelsea. This was a huge surprise as I saw securing Champions League football as more of a 2nd/3rd season goal after re-establishing ourselves as a Premier League side so this was very pleasing. However with the weight of expectancy increased, and another competition to compete in this season was going to be a struggle. New Chairman Ken Bishop and I agreed to target a Champions League spot for this seasons expectations and gave us an extremely generous £108m to compete on this front, so how did I decide to spend it? Find out below!



I fully utilised Chairman Bishop's gracious £100m + budget spending a large proportion of that over the two windows. As you'll see shortly there were a lot of outgoings and with the fact we now needed to compete on 4 fronts I decided to sign a large number of players. However sticking with my usual recruitment strategy of signing U23 players when possible. I want to build a serious long term team here with Newcastle and so we opted for players who have great potential, and give them the exposure to first team football they need.

I won't individually go over all the signings, you're welcome to ask me individual player questions if you have any but I'll gloss over the £10m plus signings. Justin Kluivert needs little introduction, son of Patrick and becoming quite the player in his own right. He was identified mid-way through the first season as someone who fits our ideology of wingers acting as inside forwards and being able to cut in and shoot/cross. £9m plus add ons will be a snippet of his true value and I was very pleased to get this one over the line. Kluivert will operate mainly on the left wing, and further back the pitch we also made another strong addition to our left side with Kieran Tierney coming in from Celtic. Once again we fended off interest from bigger clubs with the lure of immediate first team football being a key factor. Tierney is exactly the sort of player I like and age is on his side. Someone who is able to bomb forward but also isn't scared to put in a challenge. Certainly a player ahead of years in mindset and a future captain of this club. He came in to compete with Paul Dummett as our starting LB. Meanwhile on the topic of future leaders at the back, Alban Lafont the much spoken about young French keeper was brought in from Toulouse for £24.5m. This was a large outlay on an unproven goalkeeper but the potential is incredible and I hope he'll turn out to be a David De Gea esque signing. At 18 he's inexperienced to say the least, but will benefit from being our number 1 keeper and an exposure to high level first team football.

Welcome to our new midfield partnership! This was one aspect of the window I was particularly happy with. Ruben Neves came in from Wolves and Nathaniel Chalobah from recently relegated Watford. These are two players I also earmarked earlier on in our first season as players I wanted. Both were going to be playing their football in the Championship for another season and I used this to my advantage and negotiated two deals at just over £20m a piece. I have no doubt these two will be able to compliment each other well and go on to be future stars of this football club. Talking of future stars, how about my new wonderkid striker Andrea Pinamonti from Inter? Few are more highly rated in Europe and what made me laugh here was I was actually offered the Inter Milan job in the pre-season, I obviously declined and then stole one of their best youth prospects, I'm sure I'm not on their Christmas card list now! Pinamonti comes in with the world at his feet and will compete with Gayle & Martinez for our striker spots this season.

Finally a quick mention of the free transfers I picked up. I'm a bit of a fiend for this and tend to pick up players with no real place in the squad for them just because I can essentially. However a few I was happy with here. Rodri from Villarreal came in. A 22 year old Spanish Central Midfielder with bags of potential again, he offers good backup to Chalobah and Neves and really improves our squad in general. As does Daley Blind who we picked up after his Manchester United contract came to an end. Blind is a very versatile player and in a Champions League campaign will prove very handy. Sergio Canales another Spanish attacking midfielder formerly of Real Madrid & Valencia came in after his Sociedad contract expired. He offers an exciting option at CAM when we drop the 2 strikers into a 4-2-3-1. Finally wingers Jonathan Bamba and Hatem Ben Arfa the latter back for a second stint at the Toon came in to bolster our squad. Overall, a very busy incoming window.


Again, I won't individually break all of these down as a number are just loans of young players who may or not become more prominent as the save goes on so I will just summarise. I eluded to it in the previous section that there was a lot of outgoings. I felt we punched above our weight hugely last season and there were a number of players who overachieved and would struggle to reach the levels I wanted to hit this season so were let go. The likes of Lejeune, Manquillo, Saivet, Perez, Aarons and Elliott were largely players who came up from the Championship with Newcastle and weren't really the level we needed them to be so they were moved on.

There were a few contentious transfers that I had to selfishly move on. No more so than Matt Ritchie who I admit I may have made a mistake with. We signed a number of wingers and he expressed concern, I'm a stubborn man at the best of times and after our conversation didn't go too well he asked to leave. Despite being at an inflated value of £20m I couldn't find a buyer and once my mind had been made up I wanted him out of the squad so I took a measly bid from Nantes at just over £7m and he was on his way. Matt was excellent last season but at 29 and with younger players coming through he needed to go, but the manner of his departure and poor fee was disappointing. Meanwhile January saw 3 former first teamers sent out on loan. Shelvey, Mitrovic and Merino all weren't getting first team football and were all on large wages, I felt they needed to go and keep up their development elsewhere, especially Merino who is someone I think can be a future first teamer here but with the likes of Neves, Chalobah and Rodri in his way his chances were limited. Shelvey and Mitrovic were part of the 'Benitez' core of players who in the new dynamics feature were Squad Leaders so I had to tread carefully and I thought a loan would be a good first step in managing their exit from the club as I saw little future for them here. Finally January transfer deadline day saw a strange bid from Man Utd come in for our backup keeper Matz Sels. I wanted to keep Sels as he was a good mentor and understudy to Lafont. United came in with a £10m bid, I renegotiated this to £20m and surprisingly out of desperation they agreed and he was on his way. A shame but I managed to tie up a cheap deal for Angus Gunn to come in so no real harm was done.


Carabao Cup

Not much to report here. After a routine win against Bristol City we drew Arsenal and our second string suffered a narrow 1-0 loss. The board weren't particularly fussed about the Carabao and despite good intentions neither was I with a lot of other competitions to compete in now, and our arch Cup nemesis Arsenal managed to beat us again, and as you'll soon see not for the only time this season...

FA Cup

A familiar ending once again! Two routine wins against Championship sides saw us pitted against Arsenal in the 5th round. If I'm honest as soon as I saw the draw I knew our number was up as they were soon becoming our bogey side. We did play a strong side but I will gladly say that was our worst performance of the season and there weren't many comparable to it. So unfortunately another cupless year on the domestic front for us, and no Wembley days out for these expectant fans. We go again next time round!

Uefa Champions League

We were back amongst Europe's elite for the first time in over 15 years! Our path to glory wasn't going to be easy, as we'd been missing from Europe for such a long time our coefficients and stock within Europe wasn't high so we were 4th seeds for the draw. Ultimately we drew a challenging group of PSG, Atletico Madrid and Gladbach - This was going to be an interesting set of fixtures and initial thoughts was a 3rd place finish and path into the Europa League would be credible, so how did we get on?

Much better than expected indeed! We amazingly managed to finish the group unbeaten with 4 wins and 2 draws. The standout results was our 2-1 home win over PSG followed by a 1-0 reversal of them at the Parc Des Princes after a late Lautaro Martinez winner. We then finished the group with a 2-0 dispatching of Atletico Madrid. A very pleasing set of games and I was hopeful with a 1st place finish that we would avoid some of the big guns and be able to go on a bit of a run. Unfortunately our luck ended there, we were drawn against Spanish & European giants Barcelona,,,

As expected, we were defeated by Barca but not disgraced. Our first leg 1-0 defeat at the Camp Nou filled me with positivity and we actually missed several easy chances to nick something there. I thought we'd have a chance at St James's if we stole an early goal but we witnessed a Lionel Messi masterclass unsurprisingly after he was quiet in the first leg. We were very poor at home and I think our lack of quality was showing for the first time as despite our standing within England & Europe we just aren't quite on that elite level yet. However a very positive campaign and the board were more than happy with our exploits.

Premier League

We did it! Probably one of my finest achievements as a manager, certainly on this years edition but others previously too. It was a different kind of season to last year as bar the early exchanges we pretty much led the pack for the majority of the season. However we were never truly clear, we had Man Utd, Chelsea and Man City treading on our heels for the whole season and once again it went to the final day of the season. Unlike last season we held our nerve we beat Stoke 2-0 and managed to win by 2 clear points after Man Utd could only manage a draw away to Arsenal.

We went on a very similar run between November & April to last season without losing a game for a long period of time, we drew far too many and that certainly will be an area to improve next season. However overall I was absolutely delighted to win and now the expectancy will be on us to be in the mix again next season and try to show we are serious contenders for years to come. Here's a look below at how we got the points to give us that elusive title.

Player Of The Season

Lautaro Martinez

You only have to look at the above achievements that the man accomplished to see how much of an impact he was this season. He notched 21 goals in 25 Premier League starts and 30 goals in all competitions. He was pivotal to our successes and had a fantastic season. In the 'Complete Forward' role he absolutely runs that front line and we certainly will do well to keep hold of him for the future but he's an excellent striker and one I highly recommend to other managers needing a new hitman!


As I said, I had written out a comprehensive update but time constraints and attention span has stopped me from rewriting it word for word! However if you have any individual requests on player screenshots, tactics or other information please let me know and I'll happily answer.

A wonderful season for us and we did go one better and win that elusive Premier League title for the first time since 1927. Next season will be tough as the fans and board have a taste for it so we'll be expected to challenge again. Personally now I've ticked that off our list I don't feel we are in a position to dominate as some of the money changing hands between the likes of Liverpool, Man City and Chelsea etc is astonishing and we won't be on that level to compete. I'd like to focus more on the cups and have a successful Champions League run. We will see!

My next update won't be for a couple of weeks, with the holiday season almost over I'm back to work and won't be able to play as much however stay tuned and let's see how the Toon get on in 2020/21!

Many thanks for reading
Unbelievable how you achieved all this in the short period of two seasons! Can't wait to hear how this story progresses.
Incredible going to secure the league positions you did, considering the large turnover of players! An impressive defensive record in the second season certainly helped. I would imagine that with the new arrivals (probably) more settled in the coming seasons, that goal scoring record will improve too! Exciting times ahead for the Toon, bring back Andy Carroll & Joey Barton! :P

You are reading "Newcastle - The Toon Rising".

FMS Chat

hey, just wanted to let you know that we have a fb style chat for our members. login or sign up to start chatting.