Search
On FM Scout you can chat about Football Manager in real time since 2011. Here are 10 reasons to join!

Man Utd v Barca: Who has the better youth players?

Started on 19 May 2011 by Stam
Latest Reply on 19 May 2011 by NoX81
  • POSTS3
  • VIEWS8299
 
Stam's avatar Administrators Stam
11 yearsEdited
Manchester United and Barcelona have dominated European football over the last ten years, and will again meet in the Champions League final on May 28th at Wembley. Much of both clubs success must be accredited to excellent youth systems, with a number of the key players in each side working their way through the respective academy's; but who are the next superstars in the making that will keep the English and Spanish champions at the pinnacle of European football for years to come?

Barcelona enter into the final as favourites according to online betting sites, and have played an impressive brand of attacking and possession football in Pep Guardiola's reign over the last three seasons that has been rarely contained and much applauded. The side is full of international superstars, with the likes of Victor Valdes, club captian Carles Puyol, Xavi, Andres Iniesta and the mercurial Lionel Messi some of the world's best players. The common theme of these players is that they all learnt their trade at La Masia and are products of the club's stellar youth system.

Over the last couple of years a number of other youth team products have made their way through to the first team. Sergio Busquets and Pedro Rodriguez are now mainstays in the Catalan side, but who are the next young Messi's in the making?

Bojan Krkic became the youngest Barcelona player to feature in a La Liga match when he made his debut for the first team at just 17 back in September 2007, boasting a record of 800+ goals in seven youth team seasons. The diminutive attacker has been hampered by injuries this season however, and is being linked in the Spanish press this week with a move to Valencia. Jeffren is a flying winger who has made fleeting appearances from the bench for the first team over the last two seasons, whilst Andreu Fontas has been included in the first team squad on occasion this season, but the central defender has struggled to break into the side. The most promising of the current batch of players however is Thiago Alcantara, a clever attacking midfielder who has made 14 appearances for Guardiola's side this season, but will look to become a more regular feature next season.

United's stranglehold over English football in the last 15 years was been largely due to the rise of youth players into world beaters, with Scholes, Beckham, Giggs etc putting all-comers to the sword. The current side have less internally developed players in its core, but Darren Fletcher, Jonny Evans, John O'Shea and Darron Gibson have come through the ranks and are first team squad members.

Who the next big name youth product will be is yet to be seen, as the club have resorted to buying players straight into their first team, and the previously largely English or British first team is now more multicultural. Danny Welbeck, who has impressed on loan at Sunderland this season and made an appearance for England is a product of Carrington, as is Italian 19 year old Federico Macheda. However the brightest prospect for United is 21 year old midfielder Tom Cleverley, who on loan at Wigan has showed creativity, a range of passing and an excellent work rate this season; the player may very well make the Old Trafford first team next campaign.

Who do you think is the best youth prospect from Manchester United? What about the best youth prospect from Barcelona? What are your best picks from Football Manager 11? Share your thoughts below.
Lucas3's avatar Group Lucas3
11 yearsEdited
Thiago Alcântara do Nascimento and Gerard Deulofeu Lázaro
Both are incredible prospects from Barcelona. Acantara is tipped the next Xavi and Deulofeu the next Messi. Although to me Deulofeu is more like Cristiano Ronaldo, no matter who he plays like he is awesome.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MLUHU2qcuY0
If Bojan Krkic stays in Barcelona he will become the permanent "Hot Prospect" for the future.
Theres a young midfield player at united, from Manchester called Ravel Morrison and he is really talented. Very skillful, loads of flair, plays some lovely passes, has a great touch, pace, not to mention a good shot on him.

A real creative force but unfortunately the lad has been blighted by off the field problems. He's currently on an assault charge and has been accused of intimidating a witness in a robbery case before. Only young so hopefully he can sort it out because i tell you now this lad has the natural talent to be a United star of the future.

Little video of him here playing in the FA youth cup against hated rivals Liverpool at Anfield.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AB9EahZdJNA&feature=related

I particularly love the kiss of the badge directed at the Kop end after he scores.

Seriously though all the attributes, just needs to sort himself out off the pitch, he's a bit of a bad un.

Also from united Larnell Cole is very good (number 7 in the video)

You are reading "Man Utd v Barca: Who has the better youth players?".

FMS Chat

Stam
hey, just wanted to let you know that we have a fb style chat for our members. login or sign up to start chatting.