Just a simple question, which Genie Scout G rating is more accurate? Or wich one you advice to me? FM 2019 or mv? Or other custom? Best regards
![]()
Hi,
Is this referring to possibility of development or attributes rating? I have never pay attention to this.
From my own experience players with 140 CA are as good as the 170.
2026-03-21 19:48#310091 luk4sh31 :
Hi,
Is this referring to possibility of development or attributes rating? I have never pay attention to this.
From my own experience players with 140 CA are as good as the 170.
you should.. the rating result will change in best position from one or other
I have never really pay attention to those numbers. I will consider 15 a top attribute, 12 is good enough.
Physical matter the most. Not because they are consider OP but consistency affect only mental and technical attributes. (unless something has change in fm26)
Have a player ca 140 with consistent 17+ and he will be much better than 170 CA with consistency 7.
From the FM 24 manual, it does mention that physical attributes along with some key mental ones like Decisions, Determination and Positioning are more heavily rated bc they are good for all positions.
I think Match Engine was left same given the over 20 years they have been working at it.
I use the default rating that I assume the developer setup, CA does give you a good idea of how good a player is, however their personality and positional rating will also play a role in knowing if they will be able to perform to the best in regard to their attributes.
Their proficiency with their feet will also determine how good they are and I think the rating does not include that.
Traits can also make or break a player role and they have a higher priority than team instructions, however the rating does not consider this either.
Last but not least if they have a side preference when playing in central positions, I would think that also can influence how they perform and is also not considered in the ratings.
2026-03-21 22:54#310097 RPGFan :
I use the default rating
Which one? You have 4 +.grf files...
The one that the app has by default i do not change the ratings system, although one can do that.
although I'm considering increasing the weight of determination, decision and positioning, bc all position benefit from having that along with most of the physical attributes.
