I don't really know how to help you because i have the same problem:( but i don't really mind that i have it...
I play with Villa, and of course Carew is my target man and Agbonlahor is fast striker (i think he is put as advanced striker in attack) well anyways, Agbonlahor scored 34 in 35 games and i top scorrer in Prem, while Carew although is amazing for target man scored only 9 or 10, don't remember...
But as you said, I made the most of it, took Carew out, changed my formation to 4-2-3-1 deep (with DM's) and Agbonlahor still plays amazing, but the best part is, when i put Carew instead and tick target man and supply to head, he is surprisingly good...
So I think that if the tactic with target man doesn't work for you, don't use it, use what is best for your team because success of your team depends on all players, so if you have one weak link whole chain breaks, play with fast strikers if your team wins, why would you change something that is good??
For example, i like fast, fluid football with direct passes, wide, i like to use my wingers a lot, and 4-2-3-1 is a formation that i use almost in every game since fm05, of course when it suits the team well, if it doesn't 4-4-2 and 4-4-2 diamond...I experimented a lot with different tactics and approaches in earlier FM's but when I find a winning formula i don't tend to change it...So if it works for you stick with it, if i doesn't you should experiment till you find what does...
Hope i was of any help...cheers:beer
I play with Villa, and of course Carew is my target man and Agbonlahor is fast striker (i think he is put as advanced striker in attack) well anyways, Agbonlahor scored 34 in 35 games and i top scorrer in Prem, while Carew although is amazing for target man scored only 9 or 10, don't remember...
But as you said, I made the most of it, took Carew out, changed my formation to 4-2-3-1 deep (with DM's) and Agbonlahor still plays amazing, but the best part is, when i put Carew instead and tick target man and supply to head, he is surprisingly good...
So I think that if the tactic with target man doesn't work for you, don't use it, use what is best for your team because success of your team depends on all players, so if you have one weak link whole chain breaks, play with fast strikers if your team wins, why would you change something that is good??
For example, i like fast, fluid football with direct passes, wide, i like to use my wingers a lot, and 4-2-3-1 is a formation that i use almost in every game since fm05, of course when it suits the team well, if it doesn't 4-4-2 and 4-4-2 diamond...I experimented a lot with different tactics and approaches in earlier FM's but when I find a winning formula i don't tend to change it...So if it works for you stick with it, if i doesn't you should experiment till you find what does...
Hope i was of any help...cheers:beer