On FM Scout you can chat about Football Manager in real time since 2011. Here are 10 reasons to join!

A Promise I Couldn't Keep

Signed a player but had to make a promise i couldnt keep
Started on 20 January 2019 by BrawlySpade
Latest Reply on 2 February 2019 by davemaestro
  • POSTS2
  • VIEWS6349
During the first season with Leeds United I received a scout recommendation for Johannes Eggestein available on a free transfer. When trying to sign him he wanted me to promise that the club will gain promotion to the premier league in the 20/21 season. I was comfortably in mid table at the time so didn't think anything of it and he signed.

A run of really good results in the second half of the season saw us finish in second and gain automatic promotion. First season in the premier league was nothing special but Eggestein became first choice striker with 7 goals in 26 appearances. Now the season I've just finished he was the leagues top scorer with 23 (27 in all comps) the future is looking bright. He comes to me when the season ended complaining that i didn't keep my promise and now wants to leave and is refusing to sign a new contract. The promise was to gain promotion to the premier league but we have just finished 8th and won the FA cup beating Southampton 4-3.

Has anyone else had something like this? it seems a little ridiculous to me
Hi, im new in this forum but i try to answer your question.

I had broken promise to Wilmar Barrios when he wants me to strengthen the squad at attack. But i've failed and made him unhappy for months.

At conversation history i was just "try to rebuild our relationships here" but he replied with "its broken". So his morale turns to low.

But then after months he drops the concern because of my league position was good. If u don't want to lose him. Try to make a good league table position, plays him regularly, and talks good at the dressing room. By the time his concern will drop.

Btw i use Johannes Eggestein too at my Preston Save. He was good. Netted 30 goals in all competition.

Good luck

You are reading "A Promise I Couldn't Keep".

FMS Chat

hey, just wanted to let you know that we have a fb style chat for our members. login or sign up to start chatting.