It would be an early Christmas for Erik ten Hag and United, or more likely a stocking full of coal, as December would feature a slew of difficult matchups for the league leaders. Games against City, Chelsea, and Arsenal in the Carabao Cup would leave little breathing room in a month with seven games that would roll right into Arsenal on New Year’s day. Their opening game against City would be the most concerning, with it being at The Etihad, and Pep Guardiola eager to jump Liverpool in 2nd and stop United from pulling away.
The atmosphere of the Etihad would be one of a fierce rivalry, but that never made it to the field. Both sides would put on a performance so dull and tentative that they seemed to be playing for a 0-0 draw, and Marcus Rashford would turn in one of his worst performances in years. All of the action went down in a span of five minutes starting at the 15’ mark when Pedro Porro lost his head after a tussle with Jack Grealish. Grealish would knock Porro down in a tussle for the ball in the box, and Porro’s response would be to get up and absolutely wreck the English playmaker. There was no debate it was a penalty, and City appealed for a red card but didn’t get it. Erling Haaland would take the penalty, but Diogo Costa was up to the task and kept it 0-0. A failed United press would decide the game, as City would escape their third and Kevin De Bruyne would feed Haaland for the only goal of the game at 23’. The limp outing increased the volume on ‘flat track bully’ calls, ten Hag would need to do better against Chelsea and Arsenal to quiet the critics.
The second squad would scrape through against Olympiakos 4-3 to finish out Champions League group play, the win didn’t help Dortmund even with a better GD, the Greek side were through to the next round with United. The knockout stage draw would pair the Red Devils with Inter and ten Hag could turn his attention to the Premier League again. Hard to tell if ten Hag figured things out for their match against Chelsea, or if Tuchel : The Return wasn’t working out as expected. A much anticipated game against a potential title contender heading for mid-table turned into a stinker for anyone but United’s fans. United would build a 3-0 lead before halftime and double that to take the game 6-0 thanks to a Rashford hat-trick and a Jadon Sancho creative master class. Things were so bad for Chelsea that United finally managed to score goals from corners and / or set pieces, with Raphaël Varane heading one in and Bruno Fernandes scoring from a free kick. United took (27) shots with (12) on target compared to Chelsea’s (4) and (1), making it easy to see how the game finished 6-0. The surprising win rolled right into more good news for their game against Norwich, Liverpool would draw earlier in the day and give United an opportunity to take an eight point lead in 1st. A 3-1 win featured more scoring from Rashford and Fernandes, with a late lapse of concentration giving Todd Cantwell a goal at 75’. Teemu Pukki, who left for Lazio in the summer, was not on hand to make things inexplicably difficult for United.
Tuchel : The Return might turn into The Sacking at this rate.
Old Trafford would host the Carabao Cup Quarter Final against Arsenal, a game ten Hag would use his second squad for. He would wave off criticism as usual, sticking to his belief that youth players should play as often as possible and be trusted with big games. Casemiro would be suspended on yellows, so Scott McTominay would swap with Christian Eriksen to fill the void. United conspired to make the critics look right early on, but then Arsenal just completely fell apart. Eriksen, playing slightly out of position, would make a mistake in United’s third and give the ball away to Thomas Partey who would play through to Gabriel Martinelli for a comically easy goal at 27’. Arsenal would look comfortable with a 1-0 lead, but then they started to lose the script and dumped the game to United. Gabriel would foul Yaser Asprilla in the box for a penalty at 32’ that would allow Eriksen to level the score. Vitor Roque would miss the mark twice on excellent through balls from Eriksen and Hannibal, but finally covert thanks to an Asprilla pass in the box at 66’ to make it 2-1. Hannibal would be taken off with an injury at 69’ and his replacement, Fernandes, would give Vitor Roque his third blown chance as ten Hag should have been up 5-1 at this point. Arsenal would have their best chance of the second half to pull level with a free kick close to the box, but it would hit the wall and United would break forward with Jude Bellingham threading a ball through Arsenal’s back line for Anthony Martial to knock in for a 3-1 lead at 90’+2. Bukayo Saka would hit Gabriel Jesus with a suspect long ball at 90’+3 to make it 3-2, with VAR coming down on Arsenal’s side, but it would only flatter the final scoreline. Arsenal came out flat and were dominated, they were lucky to get two. The last laugh would be Arsenal’s though, not that Mikel Arteta was out to hurt anyone, Hannibal’s ankle injury would rule him out for ten to fourteen days and cause some serious roster issues.
The first squad would be back in force for Brentford, their last game before facing Arsenal on New Year’s Day, and The Bees let United roll right over them. Like the Chelsea game, the visitors never really showed up, and a 7-0 win would be the result. Rashford would have another hat-trick with Fernandes adding two of his own, Brentford only had three shots with two on target to United’s thirty three and eighteen. It’s hard to pull much out of this game aside from what United are capable of when everything is clicking, but the game that followed it left a lot of unanswered questions. The second squad would head to Saint Mary’s Stadium and lay the biggest turd of the season in an infuriating 2-0 loss. Moving Asprilla to CAM was the start of the problem, but he was hit with a groin injury just 24’ into the game and replaced by Fernandes. Even the addition of United’s centerpiece didn’t do anything, Southampton’s opening goal saw Max Cornet take a speculative shot from a mile out that somehow passed through a ton of players and caught David De Gea off guard. He clearly couldn’t see it, but from that point on the team just gave up and failed to get anything going. United’s form when their roster gets shuffled around has been horrible.
Losses bookending the month was bad enough, but United got more bad news when the Ballon d’Or voting concluded. Everyone knew it was coming after the season he had last year, but United fans had to grit their teeth as Haaland was given the award. He would top Mohamed Salah and Robert Lewandowski by a wide margin thanks to his (78) goals in (60) appearances. Just his goals alone would be more than Salah and Leweandowski’s goal involvements combined (74), truly a dominating Ballon d’Or win.