what's wrong with these new tactics?

hi
i ve been playing FM since 2005
i ve seen a lot of great tactics,like "beautiful football" and "los galacticos" or "los gunners".
i ve been looking for a while now,for similar tactics,also i ve tried to rebuild such a tactic for the 2011 edition.
up till now i ve failed.

But looking into new tactics presented for editions 2010/2011,i have some doubts.it seems all new tactics are similar,and also have, for instance, "long shots" often,"tackling" hard,"pressing" all over! that couldn't work right?and then all these "swapping positions"?? all of a sudden a midfielder is a striker and a full back a midfielder,etc!how realisticly can you use a tactic like that.
obviously none of those new tactics work for me,even after the team seems to be familiar with them in training.
are there more of you with the same problem?are there any genuine tactics out there?maybe alternatives of the "beautiful football" tactic?
i m looking for a stable 433 or 451 tactic to play with stable defence and creative atackers,short passing.
thanks for your help

here is a old one


Position Player Role Duty
GK Sweeper Keeper or Keeper Defend
DL Wing Back Automatic great combo with inside foward
DCl Centre Back Defend stoper or cover
DCr Centre Back Defend stoper or cover this depends a lot of your players i use the combo stoper cover
DR Wing Back Automatic great combo with inside foward
DMC Defensive Midfielder Defend or Trinco the destroyer player combo with the passer player
MCl Advanced Playmaker Support or Deeplying Playmaker or Ball Winning Midfilder the ball passer player combo with the playmaker player
MCr Advanced Playmaker Support or Deeplying Playmaker or Ball Winning Midfilder the playmaker player combo with the passer player
FL Inside Forward Attack or Support
FC Complete Forward Attack or Deeplying Foward Support
FR Inside Forward Attack or Support

Instructions
Philosophy Fluid
Passing Shorter
Creative Freedom More Expressive
Closing Down Press More
Tackling Default
Marking Default
Crossing Default
Roaming More Roaming

now if hi understand you right you must change the filosofy to rigid and roaming to stick to position try to put the creative freedom to more discip.

thanks a lot mate,will try it right away