On FM Scout you can chat about Football Manager in real time since 2011. Here are 10 reasons to join!

A good young defender

Started on 13 July 2012 by Vad1802
Latest Reply on 19 June 2013 by Significance
  • POSTS18
  • VIEWS40350
I am looking for a good youngster who can play in the defence. 17-21 years old.

I have a lot of money so plz come with some good youngsters.
I am Manchester United
Kyriakos papadopalous (dc)
Romario (dr)
ok. thanks
Dede- Vasco de Gama
Danny Wilson
otamendi is a pitbull , buy him!! he is the next puyol in real life;)
Mário Fernandes (Grêmio)
The problem is that most of the excellent defensive youngsters are playing for your rivals.

For example, for me, easily one of the best young DC's is Danny Wilson (SCO/L'Pool). At 19, he spent a year on loan with me at Dortmund, and was a fantastic back-up with Hummels and Subotić.

Then, you have Raphaël Varane, of Real Madrid, who is also one of the next big things in the coming generation. Of course, the problem is that, he already plays for RM. Why would he come to Manchester when he is only 18/19.

Other favourites are Kyriakos (Schalke 04) Stefan de Vrij (Feyenoord), and of course, City's pair: Savić and Boyata.

If you really want a young defender, I'd go for Mateo Musacchio from Villarreal. A physically strong CB can only rarely be a complete idiot.

BTW: Why don't you buy Ryan Shawcross? He IS an idiot, but he makes up for it...
Have a look at for a complete list.

My Recommendations

Sebastian Toro (Colo Colo)
Siyanda Xulu (Mamelodi Sundowns)
Craig Dawson (WBA) -> scores plenty of goals for a defender
Diego Polenta (Genoa)

Ricardo Rodriguez (Zurich)
Jerome Roussillon (Sochaux)

Sime Vrsaljko (Dinamo Zagreb) -> everyone seems to buy him in their stories
Michel (Almeria) -> really attacking RB

From these players, I have played with Toro, Polenta and Rousillon.
I can vouch for their quality.
I have either played against the others or scouted them at some point.
Martin Montoya is class. Could do great with a team that wants to challenge for the title. Could do WONDERS for a mid-table team. You'll have to manage him the right way though.

Papadoupoulous from Schalke is also a great central defender, as is Dede from Vasco - who, in my friend's save, have scored a great lot of headers. I'm playing a Liverpool save and the entire Liverpool back-line is quality with Sebastian Coates, Daniel Agger and Danny Wilson my star men. Phil Jones and Chris Smalling also become great center-backs for United. Especially Phil Jones. That kid is quality.
i dont rate kyriakos papadopolous. he lacks the composure and concentration to become a top centre back .same as with martin montoya.

real decent young centre backs are really hard to come by. but i would suggest mikel san jose because he is good at pretty much everything and has no real weaknesses
montoya is quality at rb thou i suggest harry maguire from sheff utd he only 19 but has played a lot of football for his age and can get him for bout 2.5 mill
Hey. i have a question. what do u think about Andrea Signorini from Benevento?
Kara (Tromso) and Casemiro (Sao Paulo) are the best! Buy them and you'll win everything!

You are reading "A good young defender".

FMS Chat

hey, just wanted to let you know that we have a fb style chat for our members. login or sign up to start chatting.