On FM Scout you can chat about Football Manager in real time since 2011. Here are 10 reasons to join!

RDF's Kool Underdogs FM20.4.1

A solid FM20 tactic designed for the underdogs who haven't been given a chance. Underdog tactic for FM2020 with cautious shape/formation. Requires hard work, stamina and decent technical skills.

By on May 16, 2020   47979 views   14 comments
Download Now
Downloads: 8225 / Size: 43.2 kB / Added: 2020-05-16
Football Manager 2020 Tactics - RDF's Kool Underdogs FM20.4.1

Today I’ll be sharing a tactic I recommend to use for Underdog / Sub-top clubs; teams in relegation battle, good enough to compete for Europa League / Mid-table.

It's cautious shape/formation and will require to have players who are will work hard, have the stamina to work hard and okay technically.

Credit to Sanders for testing the positive mentality. Great recommendation from him which made me also look into the Attacking mentality too. His results are with Preston

What mentality to use?

Cautious Mentality - This is for the REAL underdogs. Teams that don’t have the resources to like the other teams. Perfect example of this is Paderborn (check results)

Positive Mentality - This is for underdog teams expecting to stay in the league but not as good as others. Example is Preston (check results)

Attacking Mentality - This is for decent sides in the league. Those good enough to compete in Europe. Example is Espanyol (check results)

The Shape

We’ll be using a 4411 2DM shape. This shape is designed to be able to press all over the pitch but with more protection in front on defence making it difficult to break down.

I’ll start with both central defenders. Both are Ball Playing Defenders, whilst one focus more on passing first and other more willing to dribble with the ball.

Both full backs will aim to get closer to the wingers to form a good overlapping relationship on field. The Support duty gives them the responsibility to support the midfield too.

The DM partnership allows one to focus on creating from deeper areas whilst other aims to win the ball as quickly to set the more creative players.

The wide players in midfield will focus on getting the ball wide, down the flank to get a lot of crosses in for the players inside the box.

The AM tries to break the opposition from playing out the back comfortably. He also makes forward runs to support the lone striker and also to be on the end of chances.

AF is the main source. He will be your match winner most of the times. He will need to be the outstanding player of the team.

Type of Players

Typically, you want players that are suited to the role. This tactic is very demanding and will require to have players who are high in work rate, stamina, determination and who are also good decision makers.

Both Full backs should be pacey players, who can also cross the ball and be okay at defending. Both CBs should be okay with pace as they will be defending very high, having good ball control/passing is a huge bonus!

BWM can start a lot of attacks, so you want a player who is comfortable on the ball and who also has good ball winning abilities.

Deep Lying Playmaker, well, needs to be a good playmaker. The better the playmaker the better the build up play. He needs to pick the right pass.

Both wingers can be either, more physical players one will run for your team, good work rate and team work, stamina and agility. a Milner type player will be great. But also good at crossing, they need to help provide assists. Or they can just be your traditional winger type, someone with good pace, off the ball, dribbling and flair.

Attacking Midfielder should have good Second Striker abilities. Some one who can finish, shoot from distance and someone who knows how to make the right decisions and can anticipate situations.

AF, has to be pacey, good off the ball and finishing. He will be your main player

Tactic Tweaking

You can change between the 3 mentalities, you can make the judgment during matches or by reading scout reports/media prediction/match odds.


I recommend using the RDF training guide.

Testing - Results

Preston (positive mentality)

Paderborn (cautious mentality)

Espanyol (attacking mentality)

Download Now
Downloads: 8225 / Size: 43.2 kB / Added: 2020-05-16
RDF Tactics's avatar
About RDF Tactics

RDF is an FM Scout tactic creator who just loves to experiment. His quirky personality shines through his tactics but his main goal is create tactics/content that both achieves enjoyment and results.

Your content on FM Scout

We are always looking for quality content creators, capable of producing insightful articles. Being published here means more exposure and recognition for you.

Do YOU have what it takes?
Like & Subscribe

Like our Facebook page & Subscribe to our YouTube channel!

Discussion: RDF's Kool Underdogs FM20.4.1

14 comments have been posted so far.

  • Steview's avatar
    Would his be a good tactic for Burnley or would you use the other one you posted?
  • RDF Tactics's avatar
    @serggiu its okay, but the more attacking mentality, the less possession you might get because more risk taking
  • Chipster777's avatar
    Thinking of using this as my away tactic against the big boys in the Prem. Got Ipswich Town to a few 5th place finishes but always get spanked by the likes of City and Liverpool away
  • serggiu's avatar
    How is the possession? And I assume it will work for bigger teams as well lol
  • RDF Tactics's avatar
    @srgmgvdv - yes! no set piece routines have been set up, i have left on default. i do have routines somebody has given me today if anyone wants them? but i don't use them in these tactics
  • srgmgvdv's avatar
    This results without long throw-ins useing?
  • VicVDM's avatar
    Just got drawn as Bruges in a group with real madrid, city and atalanta. This is gonna be a great test... ;p
  • VicVDM's avatar
    Alright, thanks man! I'll let you know how it went!
  • RDF Tactics's avatar
    @VicVDM - Hey! i think it will work well for Champions League games. If Dinamo Zagbreb and playing against Elite team like Barcelona or Munich, i would use Cautious mentality
  • VicVDM's avatar
    Hey, do you think this works for champions league matches against big teams? F.e. dinamo zagreb, club bruges etc... against the big teams?
  • RDF Tactics's avatar
    @Rogy7 - i like to think so, yes. The aim to the training guide is also improve morale (happiness) and improving players for the tactic. As the season goes on, i can see players getting better and playing better.

    i will have some examples. But my striker at Paderborn didn't start well but as he got better at his training i set him to improve, his performances got better
  • RDF Tactics's avatar
    @GfxJG - with cautious mentality. i have some more screenshots of results, what i tweaked and when i tweaked.

    Also with other management stuff like staff signings, training and dynamics
  • Rogy7's avatar
    Does the training matter
  • GfxJG's avatar
    1st place with PADERBORN, what the shit... Gotta try this
FMS Chat

hey, just wanted to let you know that we have a fb style chat for our members. login or sign up to start chatting.