⭐️PATREON - Tactics, Rebuild Files And More!⭐️ - Patreon!...
To Stay in touch with myself, to ask any questions or request tactics, follow my socials <3
Twitch TwitterYoutube Discord Instagram
Tactic TESTING
Tactic Screenshots
Any issues with tactics? Shoot me a message on here or take your pick of the social medias. Nothing nicer than turning your saves around, been feeling the love a lot lately <3 - Josh
I always take time to respond to messages, and have many happy conversations with you all!
Discussion: The Strikerless META FM26 Tactic | HIGH GOAL SCORING MACHINE
35 comments have been posted so far.
I agree with you on this point, I also sent a PM to Stam some time ago to stop SOME post like the one you mentioned that are only insulting Josh, that, besides not adding any useful content to the discussion, is also illegal. For the other constructive discussions as I already stated in my other post I am always ready to hear everyone's opinions, suggestions and advices about other creators tactics as I do for mine. Many of the tactics emulations I made on my channel and posted here came from my followers and viewers's advices when they asked me to emulate this or that manager's tactic and how should they do if they are struggling in attacking or in defense and so on, and this is what I always like and welcome, an interesting discussions about football manager and football tactics in general too.
Bellend and his bellend non tactics. Sick of the sight of his fat moon head. Everywhere I look hes there with more of his crap. Absolutely sick of him.
PLS Admins, STOP THIS SHIT USER
babe wake up, world's most annoying person posted another tactic on fm scout
These types of comments offer nothing and are just personal attacks.
I welcome the discussion regarding a consistent testing environment and clear post guidelines but sometimes people go too far and make it personal, that said things have improved considerably since I first raised my concerns with Stam. The discussion is a lot more constructive now, which is the way it should be
Upload tactics all day long. I love the idea of building tactics. He's doing something I would love to do, but I'm afraid with my life, and I'm sure it's the same for others we don't have time. So full credit for josh for making a living from it
But when you continually upload tactics, and the community are having the exact opposite results that he is posting. Then questions need to be asked. Are these results built without the use of the editor.
Why can't you as a site, from now on. Have strict guidelines for people who upload tactics. Full screen images. Player progression, players stats, league tables, schedules etc.
Please don't take the community of FM scout for morons. Some of us having been coming to this website for YEARS. Please notice the feedback in other creators tactics. Are you not scratching your heads wondering why we are boggled by the results that he posts vs the results we get?
FULL TRANSPARENCY is needed, especially when he's giving names to his tactics to drive traffic to this site. It's not beneficial for josh nor is it for veteran players, or new players who are using these tactics and being sacked by Christmas.
PLEASE DO MORE ABOUT THIS
Enjoy your Christmas everyone
I think that says it all for me as to why he's using THIS page. If someone actually likes this tactic and has a few questions... they'll be waiting a long time, because he doesn't read the comments. That's just really bad, because it's solely about promoting his channels.
He had 4,135 downloads on some of his tactics in November and now he is down to less than 500 on average as they have been tested. Latest less than 300. This one 44 times.
Also, he publishes minimum data, so you will click his video (understand that is business).
What credibility this website has if it allows people to publish worthless tactics and the only reason for it is to use website traffic.
The titles are wrong. Tactics results should validate if tactics is good or bad not the author. Unless the author has a reputation of creating a valuable content, and not questionable like this guy.
You are the only one who can do something about it. All we can do is making comments but I guess it is very hard to convince you.
Regardless, this conversation is completely irrelevant to the tactic here and needs to stop. I'll be away for the rest of the day, so will check again tomorrow.
And yes, it might be a harsh word, but player stats are NEVER shown in the videos, nothing at all. The tactics were tested by the people who also commented here, and the results NEVER agreed, and the editor is definitely enabled. Now, please put yourself in the shoes of a new member, reads this title, thinks, "Great, finally a good tactic," and then gets relegated with their team, even though they clearly scored 100 points.
About politics, the truth is I don't have any. Users who prove they can submit tactics properly (meaning without me having to edit them because download link doesn't work for example) are getting promoted to the tactician membergroup which practically gives them the privilege of bypassing the queue.
A queue I haven't had time to check for nearly a month due to personal reasons and sadly there's no other admin or moderator who can or wants to handle validating.
My annual break will kick in soon but I'll try my best to go through the queue over the next few days and clear as much as I can.
I have made countless test of his tactics which have been uploaded here. In some cases the results are not even close. I'm a big believer that holiday testing doesn't work so does his testing.
You watch his videos and there is nothing there either. He tends to hide all his data so people couldn't make a conclusion is this achieved by editor or real one.
You also stated that using words like “the best” was not allowed here. However, he used a synonym of that term instead. He also bypassed that rule by posting an image with the word “PERFECT” displayed in very large text, taking up nearly half of the picture.
@TheAvenger2101 Totally agree with you
@luk4sh31 I already took a screenshot
We're not insulting the author, but rather communicating using, let's call them, STUPID tactics that, according to some users, DON'T work.
2. The rules state: NO advertisement of any sorts. You may leave a link to your YouTube channel and Twitter in your author box. Here, it ONLY mentions the YouTube channel and Twitter, and I see the user has Patreon, Instagram, Discord... So, from my perspective, this is a violation because it's NOT just Twitter and YouTube that are linked.
3. Titles like "Check this out!" are no good.
Okay, Meta, Insane etc is of course better, of course
On a side note, I don't appreciate the personal attacks at all. That's also against the site rules. So tread carefully.
it's fm calciomaestro
In my videos I explain the real life tactic analysis with a tactical board and then show my FM stats, highlights and finally how to create the tactic , in a step by step guide, so even if people do not pay in my patreon the tactic (or they can't download the fmf file because they play with playstation or xbox) they can still create it by themselves
What's your YouTube channel or website?
Stam doesn’t want to hear what the community he created has to say about the fact that he bent the rules for some people and set new ones for those who broke them.
I guess this is business, after all, for him too. Maybe if you start posting on the FM channel, he’ll be more flexible.
I almost forgot that this website has so many followers thanks to Eugene. He is the creator of FM Genie Scout, and the fact that this is the only place where you can download it (in theory) means this will always work in the admin’s favour.
I actually never followed Josh's youtube channel neither used his tactics but he is a member of this site so of course he will never get banned or his posts removed. The site rules are valid for everyone but not for him. I must admit when I check my youtube channel views sources that nearly 80% of my views are coming from this site. It was like this with my old channel and it is the same for my new channel. I tried to avoid posting here because I guess still most of the people who read my post here do not subscribe to my channel because they can just download the tactic here and don't need to watch my video neither to subscribe to my patreon and buy my tactics. That was the main reason that after seeing other creators posting the tactic here with a subunlock.io link that made all people subscribe to their youtube channel I also did that, not knowing that it was against this site rules and with that trick I got from 500 subscribes to 5000 in just 3 months, until Stam (the admin of this site) found it out in august 2024 and he told me he was very disappointed and removed my privileges and all my tactics would have been put in a validation queue and then I made the mistake to delete my channel but I was really frustrated and angry that many creators who did worse tactics than mine had many more followers than I had on youtube and I wanted to give up. After 1 month Stam gave me my privileges back and then I decided to start the new channel in october 2024 but after more than 1 year have only 668 followers. I do this tactic emulations things all on my own and test it playing myself all the games (except friendly preseason) so you will never see me posting 1 tactic a day the most I can do is 2 per week. I try to be as realistic as possible (even if I mostly obtain good results what I want to obtain mainly is the same playing style of the manager). It's not bad if a creator hopes to get money with this contents there is nothing bad, I mean there are a lot of good creators (much better than Josh) who also ask for a patreon subscription or at least a youtube subscription to download their tactics but when I see what is going on and this saga I feel really what I am doing is useless, I love tactical analysis I always loved football since I was a child and football manager since 2006 (and before I played CM 98 and other games) and my love for football has always been one of the most important things in my life. I don't blame Josh to try to get money on his youtube videos and tactic creations but if his tactics do not work and other creators whose tactic works much better (I am saying about other creators who are much better than me one of them being on the path to be a real match analyst in UK) getting not so much space here, that's not right, ( The admin may argue that this is his site and he can host who he wants and if we are not ok with that we can create our site and that actually is not wrong.) Sorry for the long reply, and thank you very much